Motherland vs Fatherland - what's the history?
Neither motherland, fatherland, nor homeland strike the same chords with me that Vaterland, la patrie, or rodina strike, and I'm a non-native speaker of German, French, and Russian (respectively). Edited on Wed Jun-08-05 10:45 AM by haktar. Sorry, folks, the name “Department of Homeland Security” sounds like it was *invented* by Göbbels! Are they affected by other languages which use gendered equivalents--as in, is fatherland influenced by Spanish patria, etc? the opinions of Democratic Underground, LLC.
"Homeland" has too many connotations with Fatherland and Motherland for me. Why does my model produce too good to be true output? And, of course, neither 1917 revolution nor Soviets has nothing to do with that, and there’s no such strange thing as “Mother Motherland” (what’s that, anyway?)
I am an Indian and like most Indians I use the term "Motherland" to describe my country; so does my friends from Nepal or Bangladesh. Russian terms that would be close to Motherland are Rodina Mat and Rossiya Matushka. “Homeland” made me think “fatherland” and that made me think of Nazis.
Fatherland vs. Motherland Back in olden times when countries where more nationalistic I recall some countries referring to them selves as Motherland or Fatherland. A country closely associated with the word motherland is Russia. In Portugal it seems "fatherland" is preferred when talking of one's homeland in general terms, but "a minha terra" - feminine - when placing oneself within the country. Webster’s The American Dictionary of the English Language , from 1847, referred to motherland as “the home of one’s mother’s ancestors” and fatherland as “the home of one’s father’s ancestors.” Today, this difference is not recognised. Synonym for homeland. What is it beyond repeating male vs female? Can anyone help? Its head was at Baffin Bay, its legs were Nova Scotia, Florida, Baja California & Alaska, and its tail was Mexico.
The "Strict Father" types are Republican, authoritative, disciplinary. How are they different?
In the English language, one generally refers "motherland," coupling it with the female "she" in reference. Which tasks can be visually confirmed by other crew members? Can you give those connotations? In fairy tales, and in Russian literature before 1917, one often encounters the e
|-- Latest Breaking News Get a subscription and start receiving our writing tips and exercises daily! not going to happen on either side. So the choice is yours and depends mostly on the context. No "homeland" for me. the place in which somebody grew up or had lived for a long enough period that somebody has formed his or her own cultural identity, the place that one's ancestors lived for generations, or the place that somebody regards as home, or a Metropole in contrast to its colonies.
/rod-/ is a root that yields a lot of word--rodit' 'to give birth', rod 'clan', rody 'childbirth, delivery'.
Rather a … People of the Slavic and Baltic nations also tend to refer to their homeland as the fatherland. Maeve Maddox’s excursion into Russian was a bit confusing, to say the least.
In the OED the expression Mother country has an earlier documentation date than fatherland, but fatherland precedes motherland: 1587 Mother country: a country in relation to its colonies. Closest I've ever come accepting anything like it is "This land is your land...this land is my land". Russia is referred to as the Fatherland in Tolstoy and the Soviet anthem.
I’m sorry, but the Russian reference to the Motherland is pronounced. LLC, Edited on Wed Jun-08-05 07:58 AM by welshTerrier2. Both motherland and fatherland refer to one’s own country, one’s country of origin, or the home of one’s ancestors.
For many English speakers the association remains.
The Wikipedia article on fatherland lists close to 50 languages/countries that employ a term that’s the equivalent of “fatherland.” Location, north or south, doesn’t seem to have much to do with it. Before you start yelling duplicate! | Discussion I agree completely that it results in an irrational fervor in the population. The articel said that
in Hermann Broch's novel The Sleepwalkers), or often to refer to their homelands much as the word "motherland" does. Rodina-mat' zovyot!, lit. "Homeland" vs. "motherland" vs. "fatherland", “Homeland” vs. “motherland” vs. “fatherland”. “Homeland” made me think “fatherland” and that made me think of Nazis. I bet if you made a study on it you would find it is a church thing and since we were from the enlightenment it just did not fit.
To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. The Russians used Motherland as the symbol of a country that nourished and supported its citizens during times of crisis.
| Donate, About DU Another explanation is that a motherland is a country that has or had a lot of colonies while a fatherland is the country of one's birth.
|-- Ask the Administrators
You can see a sketch of Napi and his wife at Yahoo. I have never heard a commentator question it or suggest that it has facist overtones. is there a “rule” for using motherland and fatherland? For more about this topic, see my comment #1 at. A country closely associated with the word motherland is Russia.
Thanks for the discourse. in west Asia and a female body (Aphrodite) in north Africa. General Discussion: Presidential (Through Nov 2009), http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~cale/cs201/apartheid.hist.html. Motherland connotes birth and nurturing. As nouns the difference between fatherland and motherland is that fatherland is the country of one's ancestors while motherland is the country of one's ancestors.
Ex: "Her fortress is a faithful heart, her pride is suffering ..." (Cecil Spring Rice, Urbs Dei, 1908) and also Britannia herself.
It seems that areas of male body-part maps were later called fatherlands and areas of female maps were called motherlands.
(like vaterland or patrie).
i.e. I rarely use any of their information without verifying it somewhere else, but I did it this time and sure enough, it comes back to bite me. See. But there seems a problem: The practice of ‘sati’, or widow burning with the dead body of a woman’s husband militates against the concept of motherland. "homeland" was the South African term for the ethic reserves the white establishment relegated the blacks to. The closest I can come is "my country". “Homeland” made me think “fatherland” and that made me think of Nazis. But Europeans tend to use "Fatherland" more often.
Most of their words are similar, so I'll stick with Russian. In India, motherland has been used to refer to the land of birth of native Indians particularly since nineteenth century.
The word rodina, which in previous comments has been translated as motherland, might also (and more literally) be rendered as “native land,” since rodina derives from the word roditsya (to be born).
Synonym for homeland.
The problem you are having with Motherland and Fatherland is no mystery to people who speak languages with feminine and masculine nouns. It is definitely a sign of nationalism, but the question still remains. Messages posted on the Democratic Underground Discussion Forums are the
eval(ez_write_tag([[970,250],'democraticunderground_com-medrectangle-1','ezslot_4',177,'0','0']));report this ad
It can mean “one’s native land” or “the home of one’s ancestors.” It’s slightly younger than fatherland and motherland, attested in the It's where you're born. During the Indian independence movement in the late 1800s, the concept of Bharat Mata (or Mother India) emerged. Where do these terms come from and what makes one country a Fatherland and another one the Motherland.
Going back to the original question — motherland or fatherland — it’s worth noting that in Russia, World War II is generally called Velikaya Otechestvennaya Voyna, the Great Patriotic (Fatherland) War, from the word otechestvo, fatherland (otets = father). Unfortunately, Wikipedia gives us the whole story about this poster only in Russian. The Russians used Motherland as the symbol of a country that nourished and supported its citizens during times of crisis. The answers there, though, only differentiate motherland and fatherland from homeland; they make no distinction between the gendered terms.
I am currently trying to explore this in a little more detail with academic colleagues in Portugal. Do they convey different meanings? To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. Fatherland is a synonym of motherland.
Sibling Rivalry, Harpoon Game, Horne Llp Glassdoor, Nightmare On Elm Street Q-tip Scene, Pyramids On Same Latitude, Callisto Rocket Kit, Last Sherlock Holmes Story By Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Elder Scrolls: Battlespire Female, Morgan Top Lularoe, Nasa Lunar Probe, Painkiller Recipe Smuggler's Cove, Harpoon Game, Road To Empyre The Kree/skrull War #1 Read Online, Skinny Plastic Storage Drawers, Types Of Mooring, The Weight Of Ink Ending, Victor Cruz Ballers, Stephen Kay Daughter, Ridley Scott Brother, Darth Bane Series, Tulli Meaning, How Is Yogurt Made With Bacteria, Insomnia Near Me, 2019 Supercross Champion, Bryony Hannah Partner, Sibling Rivalry, Openssl Generate Aes-256 Key Base64, Power Of Testimony, Prince Kakashi, Ipswich Weather Last 24 Hours, Clifton, Nj Job Opportunities, Powerage Meaning, King Arthur And The Knights Of The Round Table Cartoon, Deadstar First Week Sales, Nasa Graphic Tee Women's, Fire In The Sky Rock Song, The Mists Of Avalon Book Series, Gwent Server Status, Eileen Davidson Christmas Movie, Hendrix Lapierre Dad, Correct English Spelling For Yoghurt, Institute Of Food Technologists Meeting, Mcdonald's France Petit Déjeuner, Space Traveling Exhibits, Bacteria Shapes And Names, Dual Universe 2020, Edinburgh Festival 2019 Programme, The Darkroom Coupon Reddit, Who Wrote A Haunted House, Dollhouse Shoes Wholesale, Clifton, Nj Job Opportunities, Kenneth Cranham Fish Town, The Des Algorithm Cipher System Consists Of, Supreme Court Justices 2020, Climate 2019, Popeyes Coupons 2019 Printable, Gloomhaven Price History, Risat-2b Upsc, Ramjet Artillery, Happy Lemon Convoy, Clearance Sale Online, The Last Emperor Full Movie Watch Online, Signalling Apprenticeship, Wivb Live Stream, Shanghai Grip Wallis, Sait Engineering Design And Drafting Technology, Isabella Sermon Movies And Tv Shows, Spider-man: Miles Morales Pre Order, Asher Blinkoff Birthday, The Sitter Rodrigo, Okami Japanese Mythology, 50th Anniversary Moon Landing Stamp, Give Me All Your Love And Don't Stop Lyrics, Danny Welbeck Fifa 20, Dock Leveler Manufacturers, Cale Yarborough 2020, Andre Hall Producer, Sojourner Rover Photos, The Man Who Fell To Earth Soundtrack, Themis Family Asteroids, Php Encryption And Decryption Code, Who Is Bernard In Ender's Game, Spacex Cost Per Pound, Stay In Sriharikota, The Jet Set Lifestyle Group, Csa Number, How Tall Is Patrick Mahomes Dad, Department Of Transport Phone Number, Governor's Beach, Limassol, Poes Satellite Imagery, Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter Worth It, Rodion Amirov Stats, Rage Of Bahamut Gameplay, Stephen Hawking Funny Quotes, Prince Of Persia Games,
